• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport: Unique Italian Gelato & Creative Ice Cream Treats

Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport is a vibrant, family-owned gem located waterside at 29 W Front St, Keyport, NJ. This unique ice cream shop delights with its creative mad scientist and monster-themed flavors, serving up rich, creamy gelato imported from Italy. The colorful, monster-inspired waffle cones—some with gummy “body parts”—add playful charm. Highlights include inventive flavors like Death by Chocolate, Amaretto Chocolate Cherry, and vegan sorbets, alongside Italian rainbow cake with real almond paste. The welcoming, multigenerational team offers personalized tastings and excellent service, making every visit feel like coming home. This spot is a must-visit for adventurous dessert lovers seeking exceptional quality and warmth.

Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport at a glance

  • Address Entrance around back on waterside, 29 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735, United States
  • Phone +1 732-497-0050
  • Restaurant type Ice cream shop , Bakery , Cafe , Coffee shop .

Photos & Gallery

Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport: Reviews & Ratings

Tracy Rudzinski
5

Don't forget to go around back for the entrance! What a fun ice cream shop, with a mad scientist/monster theme and lore behind its various flavor characters! The colors are really fun and I loved the monster waffle cones complete with gummy body parts! I ended up going for the death by chocolate and hubby got the amaretto chocolate cherry, both delicious. Had to get mine in the black vanilla cone, which WILL turn your tongue black but is so perfect for spooky vibes! Also picked up some Italian rainbow cake there that was delightfully delicious with actual almond paste! For a sweet treat, be sure to stop by, they are open decently late on the weekends!

Mannie
5

Delicious and fresh. Such a great treat in summer. Were there yesterday they have so many options, we were bored of having Italian ice with colors added so called in to check if they have vegan options they don’t just carry delicious sorbets but so many different vegan options as well as no sugar added options. Friendly team and above and beyond service. Owner is really friendly and very accommodating. Must visit it’s a little hard to find as it’s facing the front of the water and address shows the street location.

V G
5

I absolutely love this place. It has so much to offer - the selection if ice creams is absolutely crazy, it seems like they have a hundred of them and some I have never seen in my entire life, big part of which was dedicated to exploring the world of ice cream. I enjoy so much trying something new each time, last time it was coffee with Kaluha and chocolate chips and OMG it was so good. The ice cream is also I believe imported from Italy, it is different and so much better, something you really can not find anywhere else. They are also very very clean, extremely patient and accommodating, they will let you taste the ice cream before hand and as much as you need. I noticed on multiple times extra attention to kids and elderly people which I think says a lot. For me, it comes from the fact it’s a family owned business, you see three generations working together and helping each other and you truly feel like you visit your family here. In these times of pandemic, it’s so important to visit family owned places, where your money go towards dance classes for one kid and college for another as opposite next big bonus for the next corporate CEO. I highly recommend Gourmet Italian Delights to anyone. They have great ice cream, wonderful people work there and you will love it . There’s also a lot of other food - soups, sandwiches, empanadas even; everyone will find something to enjoy and come back.

Location

  • Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport
    Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport
    Entrance around back on waterside, 29 W Front St, Keyport, NJ 07735, United States Hotline: +1 732-497-0050

Nestled waterside at 29 W Front St in Keyport, NJ, Gourmet Italian Delights - Ice Cream Monster Keyport is a hidden gem that goes beyond your typical ice cream experience. This family-owned haven combines authentic Italian gelato craftsmanship with a creative mad scientist and monster theme, turning each visit into a delightful adventure. The whimsical atmosphere invites you around back, where the colorful storefront and unique monster waffle cones studded with gummy body parts captivate right away.

The gelato here is extraordinary, made from imported Italian ice cream known for its creamy texture and rich flavor. Each scoop tells its own story through inventive names like “Death by Chocolate,” “Amaretto Chocolate Cherry,” and playful favorites such as “Gruesome Graham” and “Graveyard Gravel.” I especially loved the black vanilla waffle cone, a fun choice that stains your tongue but perfectly complements the spooky, playful vibe of the shop.

For those seeking variety and inclusivity, Gourmet Italian Delights shines with an impressive range of options—vegan sorbets, no-sugar-added choices, and rare international flavors. You’re encouraged to sample as many as you like, reflecting the warm and accommodating spirit of this three-generation family business. Their attention to detail and genuine care create a welcoming environment, making every guest feel like part of an extended family.

Beyond gelato, their menu surprises with Italian rainbow cake featuring authentic almond paste, flavorful sandwiches, soups, and even empanadas. The ice cream cakes they craft are show-stoppers, perfect for celebrations that demand both taste and charming presentation. Customer favorites rave about these cakes, noting their freshness and creativity.

Visiting Gourmet Italian Delights is an experience that delights all the senses: the bright colors and quirky decor, the luscious gelato packed with chunky textures, and the genuine hospitality of the owners and staff. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this spot offers a refreshing blend of artisanal quality and playful imagination that keeps you coming back for more.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
  • Service options
    • Delivery
    • In-store pick-up
    • In-store shopping
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards